I see you in the hallway, always catch my eye
A nervous smile escapes me whenever you walk by
My friends all say I should just say hi
But I can't seem to find the words, no matter how I try
Oh, it's the way you make me feel so shy
A thousand butterflies, they just start to fly
I try to play it cool, but it's so hard to hide
All the silly little things
I like your name in the books, it is only in Carterize
Wonder if you ever know how I look when you pass
My friends say just go for it, but they don't understand
Oh, it's the way you make me feel so shy

The thrill of stolen glasses when our eyes meet
But I can't seem to find the words, no matter how I try
Oh, it's the way you make me feel so shy
A thousand butterflies, they just start to fly
I try to play it cool, but it's so hard to hide
All the silly little things
Maybe someday you'll notice me
And we'll laugh about how shy we used to be
But for now I'll hold these wishes close
Cause sometimes it's the dreaming that I love the most
*